Sign in Subscribe

Why Most Investors Miss the Best IPOs

By sagebytes —

Investment Best Practices: Timeless Wisdom from Peter Lynch

IPO Insights for the Modern Investor

Peter Lynch, who retired in 1990 after making Magellan Fund the best-performing mutual fund over a 15-year period, shared valuable insights about Initial Public Offerings (IPOs) that remain relevant today. While his newsletter was written in 1993 (with his book "Beating the Street" just being published), his principles have stood the test of time through numerous market cycles.

Understanding the IPO Process

  • The Pricing Game: IPOs involve a delicate balancing act. Underwriters aim to price new issues high enough to satisfy the company but low enough to reward initial investors. This intentional "leaving something on the table" often creates short-term gains.
  • The Cycle Continues: IPOs typically come in waves during market peaks when investor sentiment is high. Between 1981 and 1993, Lynch observed several IPO waves. This pattern has persisted through the dot-com bubble, the 2010s tech boom, and the post-COVID IPO surge of 2020-2021.

Smart IPO Strategies for Today's Investor

  • Access Limitations: Just as in Lynch's day, individual investors still face challenges accessing the most attractive IPOs. If your broker offers you a "hot IPO" that institutional investors are avoiding, proceed with caution.
  • The Aftermarket Opportunity: Don't worry if you miss the initial offering. Look for bargains when IPO enthusiasm wanes, as Lynch did in summer 1992 when 70% of recent IPOs traded at or below their offering prices. Similar opportunities emerged after the 2021 IPO wave cooled.
  • Study the Prospectus: Review both the preliminary "red herring" and final prospectus to gauge investor enthusiasm and understand key details:
    • Follow the money: Where are the proceeds going? Into the company's treasury or insiders' pockets?
    • Insider selling: Be wary when founders cash out entirely, though partial selling, especially from older founders, can be reasonable.
    • Debt reduction plans: Companies that use IPO proceeds to strengthen their balance sheet often make better investments.
    • Management experience: Look for leadership with relevant industry expertise.
    • Business economics: For retailers and restaurants, Lynch suggests sales should exceed construction costs (ideally by 2:1).

Enduring Wisdom for Today's Market

  • Find Ignored Opportunities: New public companies are often misunderstood or ignored by Wall Street, creating opportunities for independent research.
  • Valuation Matters: Even in 1993, Lynch noted the importance of comparing a company's P/E ratio to growth prospects and overall market valuations. This principle remains crucial in today's market.
  • Long-Term Vision: Many household names that Lynch referenced (like Apple) have generated extraordinary returns for patient investors who looked beyond short-term volatility.

Modern Resources: While Lynch recommended newsletters like "Going Public/The IPO Reporter" and "New Issues Digest," today's investors can access IPO information through services like Renaissance Capital, IPO Scoop, and various financial websites that track new offerings.

Bottom Line: Peter Lynch's approach emphasizes thorough research, independent thinking, and a focus on business fundamentals rather than market timing. These principles have withstood three decades of market evolution and remain the cornerstone of successful investing strategy in 2025.